Is it Okay for Alcoholics to Try Drinking in Moderation?

Why Treatment Tells You to Never Drink Again

In treatment for alcoholism, most programs have taken the stance that abstinence and persistence are best. The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism describes overcoming alcohol use disorder as an ongoing process – to which many former alcoholics agree. Recovery is never over; it is an everyday occurrence to choose one’s sobriety, despite temptation. However, there are times when a person may make a mistake or choose to go back to alcohol.

In treating alcoholism, the National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism states that alcohol use disorder is a chronic relapsing disease. A chronic relapsing disease means that relapse is common with alcohol. A person is rarely treated for alcoholism only once, and that treatment is somehow a cure. This phenomenon is why so many treatment programs and centers advocate for persistent and total abstinence – to avoid as many relapses as possible. True alcoholics cannot just have one drink and stop. In many cases, this one drink leads to relapse or binge drinking.

As with any treatment for an addiction, relapse is something to avoid, but something that does happen. Relapse is common; however, it can be dangerous. So in general, it is good to avoid a relapse. This is why many treatment centers and programs utilize behavioral therapies. These forms of therapy seek to develop the skills one needs to stop drinking, build a strong support system, create and set attainable goals, and cope with triggers that may lead to relapse. As the title suggests, behavioral therapy changes a person’s behavior, helping them make healthier habits. However, healthy habits can be undone if unhealthy habits return, which is another reason why most treatment for alcoholism follows an abstinence-based model.

Does Moderation Work For Alcoholics? [Moderation Management]

Many believe that one’s willpower will diminish if one begin drinking again. What may start as one innocent drink often devolves into maybe one more, maybe one more, maybe one more. This is largely due to Alcoholics Anonymous, which has dominated research and treatment for alcoholism for decades. The 12-step program is still widely used and bases itself on complete abstinence, believing that little or moderate drinking after AA is dangerous. However, as more research is done and more approaches are taken, new methods for treating alcohol abuse are created, including the moderation management program.

Unlike AA, moderation management is a model that believes an individual can drink again – just in moderation. However, this ultimately comes down to the person: why they drink, how much they drink, and how long they have been in their drinking pattern. Moderation management believes that the kind of drinker a person is will determine if moderation or abstinence is best. In some cases, moderation management claims those they refer to as “problem drinkers” can learn to control and moderate their drinking.

In cases like this, then one would be able to drink again occasionally. This is after going through 30 days of abstinence where – like AA or other treatment programs – these individuals learn to identify and cope with triggers and create new, healthier habits. Once this is done, they may return to drinking with newfound abilities for controlling the habit. However, these individuals are not alcoholics.

Can an Alcoholic Ever Drink Again?

Truthfully, an alcoholic should not drink again, even in moderation.  Those who do well with alcohol moderation management are typically light drinkers who have not developed alcohol use disorder. Within this model, a person without addiction can be taught to change their drinking habits. However, a person who has an addiction – who cannot control their drinking and is dependent on alcohol – should not attempt moderation; instead, they should strive for abstinence. If heavy drinkers and those with alcohol use disorder attempt to try moderate drinking, they may experience several effects, including withdrawal symptoms and loss of control.

Alcoholism is a serious disease. It has many adverse side effects not only on a person’s body but also on their emotional well-being and social life. During treatment for alcohol use disorder, one has to heal each of these: their physical health, emotional state and behaviors, and relationships. There is so much work that goes into each category: becoming sober and potentially suffering through temporary withdrawal, identifying and acknowledging why one drinks, and repairing relationships that may have been harmed. While the idea of one drink can seem tempting and potentially harmless, it can undo all the work one does while in recovery. One drink is not worth letting that work go to waste. Although people make mistakes and relapses do happen, you should try to avoid falling into a relapse at all costs. Abstinence should be one’s goal.

Treatment for Alcoholism is Available in AZ

An addiction can be hard to overcome, especially addiction to alcohol. A person who becomes dependent on alcohol literally changes their brain, rewiring it for addictive behavior. From this, most treatment for alcoholism follows an abstinence-based model, hoping to avoid as many relapses as possible. But, if one feels they are comfortable with their relationship with alcohol after becoming sober, they may ask: “Can alcoholics drink” or “how much can an alcoholic safely drink?” The best and safest answer is no.

While there are some people with drinking problems who may be able to safely have an occasional drink, they are not people with alcohol use disorder. Anyone with alcohol use disorder should not drink again and should seek help to prevent relapse.

If you are experiencing thoughts that could lead to a relapse, please give call us at (888) 906-0952 for a free treatment options consultation. No obligation to enter into alcohol treatment.